I’m in two minds about this, and am interested in your thoughts.
Background:
My lad (14 and in grade 7), “must” go on a school tour to Leeupoort Prison in the new term. The school has been having trouble with discipline for the last couple years, and have put some very odd measures in place attempting to curb the smut. The extent of the problem is rather big, plenty of bullying and the like going on - the problem also rearing its head due to the ages of some of the kids - at 15/16 you should not be in primary school anymore…
Since then, they have seperated the boys from the girls, staggered the break times by gender and age and also seperated the exit routes from school by gender and age. The only reason I kept my son there was because he only had around 18 months or so left before high school and that he didnt want to leave at that point.
My son’s of the more quiet type, he’ll state his case but would rather withdraw from conflict than incite it with undue arguments.
Now the school wants them (the boys only) to attend two days at the Leeupoort Prison where they’ll be exposd to “no punches held”, “in the face” reality of prison.
I disagree, on the one side, the majority 13/14 year olds are still just little kids. Their emotional maturity might not be up to “in the face” reality, they, after all, still lust after Hannah Montana and think Camp Rock is the ultimate movie EVER.
On the other hand, there are the handful problem children, whom this type of outing might benefit. But I dont know, I personally dont think kids that age really have enough life savvy to associate prison with bullying and/or typical boyish naughtiness, it might even appear glamorous to them.
I’m also not a parent that raised my kids with fear, and the newsletter just screams this to me - putting the fear of prison/god/hell/whatever it is into someone is objectionable to me, I dont believe in that type of control, logic and rationality has always worked for me as a form of discipline. I’ve never had to threaten either my sons with anything, I would simply point out to them what might go wrong or what DID go wrong and it worked wonders on their behaviour.
I think the idea might be viable for older kids - 17/18 year olds perhaps, which is generally also the age that things can go mightly wrong .
Opinions? Would you let your son of 14 go?
http://johannesburg.olx.co.za/school-tours-to-prison-correctional-services-iid-67991337